Colour or B&W

I posted two images on my Facebook page the other day, and was quite taken aback by all the comments I got, you see I asked if they preferred the Colour or the B&W version, of exactly the same image.

There was a weird almost green cast to the stormy skies overhead the day I took the image at Campbell’s Cove, now I am often the first to jump on a good B&W, I love them to pieces, but more and more lately I have been using colour. There is something almost surreal and ethereal about the colour in the first image……what do you think?

Which do you prefer?

~ Julz